Welcome to Katrina’s Aftermath, a restaurant started after the disastrous hurricane, a symbol of the dedicated people of the region who rebuilt after others predicted it could not be done. Mary Elizabeth, her cousin and best friend inadvertently stumble upon a woman breaking up with Everrett Schnaydre while eating at popular Katrina’s Aftermath. They film the scene and upload it before any of them have time to think better of it. Later on they realize they created a YouTube sensation called Real Reality.
Mary Elizabeth, a respectable Catholic school librarian, cannot believe anyone would drop a man as perfect as Everrett. Unfortunately, she does not keep her opinion to herself and soon crashes, while disguised, one of his future dates, chewing out not only the woman dumping him, but Everrett for picking such an inappropriate woman in the first place.
Everrett sets out to find and punish the culprits who filmed and shared one of his most embarrassing moments. In the meantime, he ends up dating the Little Church Mouse from his mother’s church.
They make a perfect couple but he feels the need to help Mary Elizabeth avoid her impulsive side. His research suggests Domestic Discipline might be the answer.
He opts to forget his quest for revenge, so long as the producers of Real Reality stay out of his current love affair.
Little does Everrett know that Mary Elizabeth is the culprit. What will he do when the truth comes out? Will Mary Elizabeth ever be able to sit comfortably again?